Make your own free website on Tripod.com
votefix
PA election reform status
Home
Vote Fix Links
Paper Ballots, Emergency Ballots, All-Mail Voting
Investigation-less election
Voter Registration Rolls Online?
Illegal This But Not That?
Solution or Problem: Federalize Voter Registration for Federal Elections
PA Power Insight
Myth or Fact
Question Them All
"little" Fraud?
Assorted Items
PA Watch
Populism vs PA Constitution
2007 Watch: PA Constitutional Convention
Move toward PA Con-Con
Guidelines for Variety election issues and observing at the Polls
Initiatives and Referendums: Gutting Republicanism
No Voter ID = Passport to Fraud
Illegal Immigrants Voting in U.S. Elections Facts
Goals of HAVA:
Paper Ballot Make It A Voter Choice
PA SB 977 and HB 2000
Both Sides: Electronic Paperless (Selker) vs Paper (Mercuri)
Know It: Second Chance Voting
Holding Breath Will Fayette Purchase Paper Ballot eScan and Electronic eSlate?
Discussion Sites
All laws repugnant void
Activists Absent
Board Discussion
Chat
Opinion None of the Above
To Show or Not to Show State Rep. Roberts Phone Calls
Discussion PA Politics 101.2 Media Woke Up to 1 Man Agenda?
Discussion PA Politics 1000.2 PA Clean Sweep's Reform Agenda
Discussion PA Politics 102
Voter Registration Lists
PA Law Changes First Time Voter
Discussion PA Politics 101
Discussion PA Politics 1000.1 Candidates
Lawmakers Arrogance
Blogging Net the Truth Online
Hodgepodge
Voting Technology 2006
e-Voting Truth
Should taxpayers fund WW2 memorial with religious engravings?
Net the Truth Online About Election Fraud
Issue File Voting by Mail
Powerful Information
Citizen Advisory Group Proposed
Demand PA SURE used
Inspector/s of Voter Registration
Interviews of Note
SURE about SURE
Motor Voter Law and Deceased
Back to the Future?
John Fund's Political Diary
Year 2000 Highlights Palast Update
Buchanan Vote 2000 Hoax
Fraud 2000: The Confusion
Fraud 2000: Holes
Fraud 2000: The Machines Background
Fraud 2000: Quote of the Millennium
Fraud 2000: Spotlight
Fraud 2000: Undervotes Trail-less
Fraud 2000: Built on the Past
Fraud 2000: Solution in search of Problems
Fraud 2000: Recounting the Ways
Fraud 2000: Dimples
Alert: Fraud 2000
Fraud 2000 Proof
Fraud 2000: Flaws
Fraud 2000: Courts
Fraud 2000: Count and Recount
Fraud 2000: Count and Recount 2
Fraud 2000: Analysis Debate
Fraud 2000: Past to Future
Ballot Fraud of Old
1984 Florida Ballot Problems
Local, State, National Election News
Daily Developments
Voting Fraud Tale Spin
Discussion Internet Free Speech on Trial?
STOP tax reform plan Guts PA Constitution
PA Constitution Doesn't Need Makeover
About Vote Fix
Why Vote Fix Is Up
Overview
Security concerns electronic voting
Paper/Opti-scan vs Touch-screen
Voter Confidence/Increased Accessibility Act 2003
Vote Fix Guestbook
PA election reform status
Fayette County Watch
Election 2007 Watch Fayette Politics
United States a republic, not a democracy
Suggestions
Voter Identification (ID) Proof
Citizens Demand Security
Solutions Here
Federal Legislation Update
Testimony HAVA
Net Voting
So Little time
Useful Items
Comments on voting machines
Public Comment on voting machines
Supporting material
Link resources submitted to commishes
Vote Fix Research
Contact/Voice a View
Motor Voter Happenings
Trail of Treachery Chad-Fraud
Fraud 2000: How it went
Fraud 2000: How it Went Then
Trail of Treachery: Varied News & Opinions
Track Vote Fraud

PA Report updates planned

Pennsylvania Legislature Approves Major Election Reform Bill; Voter Identification & Provisional Ballots Among Issues Addressed in Legislation.
PR Newswire, Nov 27, 2002
 
 
The Pennsylvania General Assembly has given final approval to legislation that would enact numerous election reforms in the Commonwealth, making vast improvements to the manner in which elections are conducted in Pennsylvania. The passage of this measure comes on the heels of the federal Help America Vote Act (HAVA), which was signed into law by President Bush in October.
 

A key provision of the bill will address any disputes that may arise on Election Day where voters may, because of no fault of their own, find that they are not in the poll book but are in fact registered. Under Senate Bill 824, a voter who claims to be registered to vote but whose name does not appear on the election rolls will be permitted to cast a "provisional" ballot, the veracity of which will be determined before the election is certified, Piccola said.

A fraud-prevention measure contained in the legislation would also require individuals who are voting at an election district for the first time to produce identification, Piccola said. It would establish standards for both photo and non-photo IDs, and allow first-time voters who do not have an acceptable form of identification to cast a provisional ballot.

Piccola said that another positive aspect of Senate Bill 824 is the creation of a Voting Standards Development Board that would adopt uniform standards for what constitutes a vote for each category of voting system used in Pennsylvania, such as punch-cards and electronic voting systems.

 

More...

electionline.org briefing on compliance of states with HAVA
 
It looks like PA is at the top of the early-bird list for compliance measures.
The report may be several months old, remember to check PA site for official material.
 

Welcome to the Department of State's website dedicated to the Help America Vote Act! The Help America Vote Act (HAVA) was passed by Congress during 2002 to prevent a recurrence of difficulties experienced during the Presidential Election of 2000.

HAVA, along with accompanying legislation from the Pennsylvania General Assembly (Act 150 of 2002), seeks to bring a level of standard to the electoral process in Pennsylvania and across the United Stated in general....

 

http://www.hava.state.pa.us/hava/site/default.asp

 

 

States are beginning to implement requirements of Help America Vote Act 2002

PA measure:  Senate Bill 824
 
Local News
Pennsylvania Legislature Approves Major Election Reform Bill
By TSN Staffwriter
Dec 3, 2002, 12:01 PST
 
A fraud-prevention measure contained in the legislation would also require individuals who are voting at an election district for the first time to produce identification, Piccola said. It would establish standards for both photo and non-photo IDs, and allow first-time voters who do not have an acceptable form of identification to cast a provisional ballot.

tristatenews.com
 
 
PA Bulletin
public hearing on March 26, 2003

 

Found this site June 9, 2003
SecurePoll Electronic Voting Update

A Derek Dictson & Dan Ray Initiative

 

November 13, 2001

 

http://www.securepoll.com/Archives/Archive41.htm

 

Pennsylvania Voting Modernization Task Force Report (in PDF) link

 

Hearing by Joint Select Committee Focuses on
Federal Election Reform Bills Impact on PA

 

compare with the PA legislation passed, especially regarding suggestions for online voting for military...

 

Piccola

 

Good resource

 

up to date June 10, 2003 electionline.org

 

 Still, the monies from the federal government may not be fully available for the kind of protected touch-screen system our commissioners might consider purchasing.

 

Be aware of the funding situation.

 

from Public Citizen Congress Watch

 

FY 2003 Appropriations Bill Allocates $1.5 Billion for Election Reform Law

 

On February 13, Congress finally approved the fiscal year 2003 appropriations bill (H.J. Res. 2), which contains a $1.5 billion allocation to carry out the mandates of the Help America Vote Act (HAVA).

 

... The funding measure provides $650 million for immediate grants to states to phase out antiquated voting machines. It is the entire amount required by HAVA for this purpose, and will be distributed to states based on population and need. The biggest winner will be California, which will be awarded more than $80 million of these funds. Other big winners include New York, Illinois, Ohio and Pennsylvania.

 

More...

http://www.citizen.org/congress/govt_reform/election/articles.cfm?ID=9053

 

 

 

 

PA Department of State:  Elections Info
 
Voting Modernization Task Force Report in PDF
 
electronic voting systems in Pennsylvania elections with recent voting machine certification by the state
 
Regular Session 2001-2002
Senate Bill 824  Current PN: 2435    
 
SENATE AMENDMENTS TO HOUSE AMENDMENTS, NOVEMBER 26, 2002
 
Pertains to referendum
 
SECTION 9.  SECTIONS 1103-A(E), 1105-A(A), (B), (E) AND (F)
 AND 1106-A OF THE ACT, ADDED JULY 11, 1980 (P.L.600, NO.128), ARE AMENDED TO READ:

 SECTION 1103-A.  PLACING THE QUESTION ON THE BALLOT; ELECTION  THEREON.--* * *

(E)  IF A MAJORITY OF THE ELECTORS OF ANY COUNTY OR
     MUNICIPALITY, VOTING ON SUCH QUESTION, SHALL VOTE AGAINST THE ADOPTION OF AN ELECTRONIC VOTING SYSTEM THE QUESTION [SHALL NOT]  MAY AGAIN BE SUBMITTED TO THE VOTERS OF SUCH COUNTY OR  MUNICIPALITY [WITHIN A PERIOD OF ONE HUNDRED THREE WEEKS].
 
OK 103 weeks = almost 2 years?   
 
Points to ponder:
 
Has the Sec. of State approved the touch-screen voting machine with the voter-verified paper trail???
 
Task Force Members
 
Section 205 of Act 150 of 2002
(February 26, 2003)
 
Josh Wilson
 
 
Touts features recommended by Task Force, including the referendum
11/5/01
 
 
 


 
 
Report and Task Force
 
 
Look at this among recommendations of Task Force
 
Counties should consider a referendum that will allow voters to decide whether electronic voting systems should be used.
 
That made it into PA Act implementing HAVA
 
Well finally notices found a bit late, it's July 21st
 
 
That's right, the 1993 Motor Voter Law created some situations:
 
Another issue the committee examined was the states Motor Voter program, which permits Pennsylvanians to register to vote when renewing their drivers licenses or vehicle registrations.  Concerns have arisen over old, invalid names not being purged from the Motor Voter system, creating a situation where one person may be registered to vote in multiple parts of the state.
 
 
 
 
 

Status:     For Immediate Release
Date:     February 3, 2003 10:40 AM EST
Attn:     All Media
Contact:     Frank Wiebe
(949) 200-4000 x102
E-mail: fwiebe@accupoll.com
TICKER:     ACUP
 

IRVINE, Calif. -- (BUSINESSWIRE) February 3, 2003 -- Voters have made their intent clear -- voters prefer to review their votes when the votes have been recorded on paper.

The approval of a voter verifiable printed paper record produced simultaneously with casting an electronic ballot won by a landslide, in separate surveys conducted in California and Pennsylvania.

In a recent California telephone survey, 80% of active voters randomly polled said they would have more trust in an election if they could see their vote recorded on paper as part of the process of casting a ballot on an electronic voting station.

Pennsylvania voters who participated in shadow voting with AccuPoll (OCT BB:ACUP) during the November 5th general election agreed after using the AccuPoll equipment. The AccuPoll voting station has a touch screen but prints a paper record of the voter's cast ballot (a "Proof of Vote") for the voter to review.

This voter verified paper record can be audited against the cast electronic ballots to insure the integrity and accuracy of the election and hand counted in the event of a recount. Voters who tested AccuPoll were asked to complete a survey on their experience for the County Commissioners. More than 80% of the voters who tested the new AccuPoll equipment voiced their approval of the voter verified paper record and the ease of the overall voting experience.

Such survey results are a vote of confidence for the future of election reform, because first generation touch screen systems currently being adopted have not won public confidence. Everyone agrees, it's time for a change, but pure touch screen systems are not being embraced by the public. Voters report confusion with the touch screens and express little confidence that their choices were actually recorded properly in invisible electronic files.

Professional studies, such as those of Dr. Rebecca Mercuri (Bryn Mawr College) have demonstrated that touch screens can fail in ways that cause them to improperly record votes. Experience in live elections in 2002 in Florida and Texas revealed numerous incidents of failures to record or tally votes from pure touch screen systems.

AccuPoll is proud to offer a new generation of voting equipment that combines the latest touch screen usability and the conclusive voter verified paper records preferred by voters and required for auditable results.

About AccuPoll Holding Corp.

AccuPoll, an Irvine-based developer of elections equipment has excited voters, elections officials and special needs advocates in the United States and several European countries with an innovative new approach to recording and counting votes.

Combining modern touch screen input with the confidence of a voter verified printed paper record, AccuPoll allows each voter to see their vote recorded and creates a permanent audit trail of the election as recently mandated in the "Help America Vote Act of 2002."

AccuPoll works with all levels of government to ensure that AccuPoll's innovative technologies address the needs of voters, the processes of elections and the existing infrastructure to insure the integrity, security and accuracy of elections.

AccuPoll makes every vote count by counting every vote. For additiona information please visit www.accupoll.com.

More...http://www.smallcapreview.com/acup.htm

Unfortunately, though AccPoll apparently was tested for use in PA, it is not among the machines certified yet by the state of PA.
 
ELECTRONIC VOTING SYSTEMS IN PENNSYLVANIA

In 2002, two laws that affect the electronic voting system examination process in Pennsylvania were enacted.  The federal Help America Vote Act (HAVA) was signed into law on October 29, 2002.  HAVA creates the Election Assistance Commission (EAC), which will provide for testing, certification, decertification and recertification of voting system hardware and software by accredited laboratories.  In response to HAVA, the Pennsylvania General Assembly enacted Act 150 of 2002, which was signed into law on December 9, 2002.  Act 150 requires that an electronic voting system be approved by a federally recognized independent testing authority and that it meets any voting system performance and test standards established by the federal government before it can be examined by the Secretary of the Commonwealth. 

   

Following is a list of all electronic voting systems currently approved for use in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania:  (Please note the date of approval for each system, as many of these systems were approved prior to the development of any national performance and test standards.)

 

More...